International Issues in Dependency Court Cases
J. Dean Lewis, Judge (retired)
Former Member, National CASA Association Board of Directors
Past President, National Council of Juvenile and Family Court Judges

 

Summary
The era of extended family members residing in the same home town or even the same state is over. Child welfare cases increasingly involve interstate and international placement options.
 


Article

The dependency court is charged with establishing a permanent plan—in an expeditious manner—for each foster child. In order to develop an appropriate permanency plan, the court must have reliable information regarding all potential relative caregivers who may be able to provide the dependent child a safe and stable home. The era of extended family members residing in the same home town or even the same state is over. Child welfare cases increasingly involve interstate and international placement options. These examples illustrate only a few of the possibilities:

  • A child is illegally transported into the US by human traffickers and comes into foster care as a victim of sexual exploitation. There are allegations that her parents in South America allowed her to be taken to the US.
  • Two parents and their three children enter the US illegally and give birth to a sibling in this country. All children are placed in foster care as a result of a dependency finding. The parents are deported, leaving their four children—three of whom are in the US illegally.
  • Mother and father meet while attending college in the US. Mother is a US citizen and father is a German citizen. They have a child in the US and later separate. Father returns home to Germany. The child comes into foster care as a result of his mother’s mental health problems and use of illegal drugs. Mother is not a permanent placement option.
  • Father and mother marry while father is stationed in the US military in Japan. Mother is Japanese and has a child born prior to the marriage. The parents have two children together. The family is stationed in the US when the mother dies. The father petitions to be relieved of the care of his stepchild. The court grants the petition and the child enters foster care.

The child welfare agency and the court-appointed special advocate play important roles in securing information regarding potential permanency placements for the children involved in these cases. In some instances, the child welfare agency will need to employ an attorney well versed in immigration law. In all of the cases, it will be necessary to prepare a family tree and seek information regarding the location of relatives living both inside and outside of the US. What issues arise when the child in foster care is not a US citizen? Is reunification with relatives outside the US in the child’s best interest? Is separation of siblings who are in the US legally and illegally appropriate? Where does the court turn to secure a home study on those potential international placements?

Thanks go to Julie Gilbert Rosicky, executive director of International Social Service-United States of America Branch, Inc. (ISS-USA) for bringing the expertise of the authors of the articles in this issue together to help address these important issues. This issue includes the following articles:

  • Julie Rosicky enunciates many of the important issues raised in international placement decisions and provides a unique vantage point as a former CASA program coordinator in New York.
  • Felicity Sackville Northcott and Jamie Rae Harvey express concern regarding the lack of data currently being collected on American children placed overseas and question whether appropriate home studies and transitional services are being provided.
  • Jacqueline Bhabha reminds us that while the law favors family reunification, this may not always be in the best interest of children involved in certain international placements.
  • Howard Davidson addresses that issue and proposes five principles for juvenile courts and child welfare agencies to follow when determining the appropriate placement for unaccompanied and undocumented immigrant children.
  • Ilze Earner offers significant insights regarding factors to consider when working with immigrant families.
  • Alan Dettlaff offers advice to child welfare agencies working with immigrant children and their parents.
  • Chris Nugent explains the provisions of Special Immigrant Juvenile Status (SIJS) and encourages all members of the child welfare community to integrate considerations of a child's eligibility for SJIS in their work with immigrant children.
  • Paula Campbell offers web resources.
  • National CASA announces that registration is now open for the 2008 National Conference, held in Washington, DC June 7 – 10.

As a judge presented with the issue of a potential placement of a foster child with parents or relatives located outside of the US, know that you can secure a home study by working with your local child welfare agency. The local agency will process this request through the state agency, which will work with ISS-USA to secure the home study you need to make this important permanency placement decision.

 

Go Back

 The Judges' Page Newsletter  |  National CASA Home  |  Contact CASA  |  Support CASA


National CASA Association   •   100 W. Harrison St. - North Tower Suite 500
Seattle, WA 98119   •   1 800 628-3233